The BIFL List

13 picks

Toys and Games

Toys and games that outlast the childhood they were bought for, in steel, beech, sisal and plastic that does not perish.

A toy has a harder life than most things in a house and a shorter one, because most are built to survive a season of enthusiasm rather than a childhood. The ones here are the opposite: pressed steel, beech, sisal and plastic moulded so precisely that a brick from 1958 still grips one made this morning. None needs a battery and none has a speaker. The two dartboards are here on the same argument: a sisal face closes behind the dart rather than filling with holes.

Some buy links are affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How this is funded.

At a glance: Toys and Games picks compared, with buy links
RankPickBrandWhy it lastsAmazon
1Magna-Tiles Classic 100 Piece SetMagna-TilesMagnets sealed in welded ABS, no glued seams 路 Every set made since 1997 still interlocksBuy
2Radio Flyer Classic Steel and Wood WagonRadio FlyerSteel bed with hardwood stakes 路 Real rubber tyres on a steel axleBuy
3LEGO Classic Large Creative Brick BoxLEGOCompatible with every LEGO brick since 1958 路 ABS, washable, does not perishBuy
4Melissa and Doug Standard Unit BlocksMelissa & Doug60 solid hardwood blocks, natural finish 路 Standard unit proportions, so the shapes combineBuy
5Melissa & Doug Food Groups Wooden SetMelissa & DougSolid wood, painted not printed 路 21 pieces in a wooden crateBuy
6Winmau Professional Bristle DartboardWinmauSelf healing sisal face 路 Ultra thin wiring, fewer bounce outsBuy
7Melissa & Doug Wooden Chef's Play KitchenMelissa & DougWood construction, not moulded plastic 路 Doors and drawers on real hingesBuy
8Melissa and Doug 100 Wooden BlocksMelissa & Doug100 solid wood blocks, 9 shapes 路 Forest Stewardship Council certifiedBuy
9BRIO Classic Figure 8 SetBRIOBeech track, unchanged profile since 1958 路 Fits every other BRIO set, old or newBuy
10Micro Kickboard Mini Deluxe ScooterMicro KickboardEvery part sold individually, down to the bearings 路 Lean-to-steer, nothing to over-tightenBuy
11Tonka Steel Classics Mighty Dump TruckTonkaPressed steel body, not plastic 路 No batteries and nothing electronicBuy
12Strider 12 Classic Balance BikeStriderSteel frame, no chain and no brake to seize 路 Seat and bars extend as the child growsBuy
13Unicorn Eclipse Pro Ultra ChampionshipUnicornEndorsed and used by the PDC 路 Staple free, including the bullseyeBuy

Weekly email

New picks, once a week.

One email a week with new picks. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Back to all categories