7 picks
Dutch Ovens
Heavy lidded pots in bare and enamelled cast iron, from stove to oven to fire.
A heavy lid on a heavy pot, in bare or enamelled cast iron. Nothing in it can wear out except the surface: seasoning can be rebuilt on bare iron, and enamel from the established foundries comes with long warranties. Braises, stews and bread, on the stove, in the oven or over coals, and then handed down.
Some buy links are affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How this is funded.
| Rank | Pick | Brand | Why it lasts | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lodge Essential Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6 Quart | Lodge | Enamelled cast iron, no seasoning needed 路 6 quart, bread and braising size | Buy |
| 2 | Staub Pumpkin Cocotte 3.5qt | STAUB | Enamelled cast iron, made in France 路 Matte black interior enamel, browns well | Buy |
| 3 | Lodge Bail Handle Dutch Oven 7qt | Lodge | Wire bail handle, hangs over a fire 路 7 quarts, seasoned cast iron | Buy |
| 4 | Lodge Deep Camp Dutch Oven, 8 Quart | Lodge | Three legs for cooking over coals 路 Flanged lid holds coals on top | Buy |
| 5 | Lodge Cast Iron Combo Cooker, 3.2 Quart | Lodge | Deep pot plus a 10.25 inch skillet lid 路 Traps steam for no-knead bread | Buy |
| 6 | Lodge 5qt Cast Iron Dutch Oven | Lodge | 5 quart / fits a whole chicken 路 Works on all heat sources | Buy |
| 7 | Le Creuset Signature Round Dutch Oven 5.5 qt | Le Creuset | 5.5 quart, enameled cast iron 路 Cast-in loop handles, nothing to loosen | Buy |
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Essential Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6 Quart
LodgeEnamelled cast iron at a fifth of what the French houses charge for the same object, and the iron underneath is the same iron Lodge has poured in Tennessee since 1896. The enamel is the wear part: chip it and the pot still works, which is not true of a non-stick coating.
- Enamelled cast iron, no seasoning needed
- 6 quart, bread and braising size
- Moisture-sealing lid
- Oven safe to 500F
- Made by a foundry working since 1896
-
Product photograph, STAUBStaub Pumpkin Cocotte 3.5qt
STAUBEnamelled cast iron made in France, in a matte black interior enamel rather than the pale glossy kind, which is the practical difference between Staub and the alternative: a dark textured interior browns better and does not show every mark. The lid is deliberately heavy so the moisture that rises falls back, and the whole thing is oven safe to 500F with nothing on it to peel.
- Enamelled cast iron, made in France
- Matte black interior enamel, browns well
- Heavy lid returns moisture to the pot
- Oven safe to 500F
- Smooth base works on induction
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Bail Handle Dutch Oven 7qt
LodgeThe same seven quarts with a wire bail instead of side lugs, so it hangs over a fire or lifts out of an oven with a hook. Lodge has been casting iron in Tennessee since 1896, and a pot meant to hang over a fire is the shape that has changed least in all that time.
- Wire bail handle, hangs over a fire
- 7 quarts, seasoned cast iron
- Flat lid takes coals
- Made in Tennessee
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Deep Camp Dutch Oven, 8 Quart
LodgeThe camp version differs from the kitchen Dutch oven in two ways that matter: three legs that stand it above coals, and a flanged lid that holds coals on top so heat comes from both directions. It works on a hob and in an oven as well, so the legs cost you nothing indoors, and at 8 quarts it is the one to own if you cook for more than four.
- Three legs for cooking over coals
- Flanged lid holds coals on top
- 8 quart, feeds a crowd
- Pre-seasoned, made in the USA
- Works indoors on a hob or in an oven
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Cast Iron Combo Cooker, 3.2 Quart
LodgeTwo pans that happen to nest: a 3.2 quart deep pot whose lid is a full 10.25 inch skillet. The combination is why bread bakers buy it, since the lidded pot traps steam the way a much more expensive Dutch oven does, and the lid still works as a everyday frying pan the rest of the week.
- Deep pot plus a 10.25 inch skillet lid
- Traps steam for no-knead bread
- Pre-seasoned, made in the USA
- Oven safe, induction compatible
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge 5qt Cast Iron Dutch Oven
LodgeThe same generational cast iron story as the skillet, in a vessel that handles soups, stews, braises, and artisan bread baking. It does most of what an enameled French oven does at a fraction of the price, and the bare cast iron, unlike enamel, can be fully re-seasoned if ever damaged.
- 5 quart / fits a whole chicken
- Works on all heat sources
- Oven safe to 500掳F
- Tight-fitting lid retains moisture
- Made in the USA
-
Le Creuset Signature Round Dutch Oven 5.5 qt
Le CreusetCast iron under a fused enamel coat, with no coating to wear through and no handle to work loose: the loops are cast with the body. Le Creuset backs its enameled cast iron with a lifetime warranty, and the pot goes from hob to oven to table for decades.
- 5.5 quart, enameled cast iron
- Cast-in loop handles, nothing to loosen
- Hob, oven and table
- Le Creuset lifetime warranty on enameled cast iron
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Essential Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6 Quart
LodgeView on AmazonEnamelled cast iron at a fifth of what the French houses charge for the same object, and the iron underneath is the same iron Lodge has poured in Tennessee since 1896. The enamel is the wear part: chip it and the pot still works, which is not true of a non-stick coating.
- Enamelled cast iron, no seasoning needed
- 6 quart, bread and braising size
- Moisture-sealing lid
- Oven safe to 500F
- Made by a foundry working since 1896
-
Product photograph, STAUBStaub Pumpkin Cocotte 3.5qt
STAUBView on AmazonEnamelled cast iron made in France, in a matte black interior enamel rather than the pale glossy kind, which is the practical difference between Staub and the alternative: a dark textured interior browns better and does not show every mark. The lid is deliberately heavy so the moisture that rises falls back, and the whole thing is oven safe to 500F with nothing on it to peel.
- Enamelled cast iron, made in France
- Matte black interior enamel, browns well
- Heavy lid returns moisture to the pot
- Oven safe to 500F
- Smooth base works on induction
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Bail Handle Dutch Oven 7qt
LodgeView on AmazonThe same seven quarts with a wire bail instead of side lugs, so it hangs over a fire or lifts out of an oven with a hook. Lodge has been casting iron in Tennessee since 1896, and a pot meant to hang over a fire is the shape that has changed least in all that time.
- Wire bail handle, hangs over a fire
- 7 quarts, seasoned cast iron
- Flat lid takes coals
- Made in Tennessee
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Deep Camp Dutch Oven, 8 Quart
LodgeView on AmazonThe camp version differs from the kitchen Dutch oven in two ways that matter: three legs that stand it above coals, and a flanged lid that holds coals on top so heat comes from both directions. It works on a hob and in an oven as well, so the legs cost you nothing indoors, and at 8 quarts it is the one to own if you cook for more than four.
- Three legs for cooking over coals
- Flanged lid holds coals on top
- 8 quart, feeds a crowd
- Pre-seasoned, made in the USA
- Works indoors on a hob or in an oven
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge Cast Iron Combo Cooker, 3.2 Quart
LodgeView on AmazonTwo pans that happen to nest: a 3.2 quart deep pot whose lid is a full 10.25 inch skillet. The combination is why bread bakers buy it, since the lidded pot traps steam the way a much more expensive Dutch oven does, and the lid still works as a everyday frying pan the rest of the week.
- Deep pot plus a 10.25 inch skillet lid
- Traps steam for no-knead bread
- Pre-seasoned, made in the USA
- Oven safe, induction compatible
-
Product photograph, LodgeLodge 5qt Cast Iron Dutch Oven
LodgeView on AmazonThe same generational cast iron story as the skillet, in a vessel that handles soups, stews, braises, and artisan bread baking. It does most of what an enameled French oven does at a fraction of the price, and the bare cast iron, unlike enamel, can be fully re-seasoned if ever damaged.
- 5 quart / fits a whole chicken
- Works on all heat sources
- Oven safe to 500掳F
- Tight-fitting lid retains moisture
- Made in the USA
-
Le Creuset Signature Round Dutch Oven 5.5 qt
Le CreusetView on AmazonCast iron under a fused enamel coat, with no coating to wear through and no handle to work loose: the loops are cast with the body. Le Creuset backs its enameled cast iron with a lifetime warranty, and the pot goes from hob to oven to table for decades.
- 5.5 quart, enameled cast iron
- Cast-in loop handles, nothing to loosen
- Hob, oven and table
- Le Creuset lifetime warranty on enameled cast iron
Weekly email
New picks, once a week.
One email a week with new picks. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.